Established in 1976 by
Mrs. Fran Duncan

2008 Awards
VANCOUVER SCHOOL DISTRICT MODEL UN
Dr. Beverly Questad, VSD MUN Coordinator
Skyview High School, 1300 NW 139th St., Vancouver, WA 98685
Phone: 360-313-4200 - - Email -Fax: 360-313-4201

Judging Criteria for Position Paper Preparation

POSITION PAPERS

*Strong research indicated
through elaborations and examples

*True country position
Complete and with Professional Voice

* Grammar: Fluency and Conventions

First Place: Elizabeth Kaley, SHS
Second Place: Emma Hallas, SHS
Third Place: Sierra Gernhart, SHS
Fourth Place: Julie Baumgardner, SHS, and Nick Shaw, VSAA
Honorable Mention: James Bryant, SHS
Committee One: Mr. Jeremiah Thompson, Moderator
Best Speaker Awards
Committee Two: Ms. Jessica Ruso, Moderator
Best Speaker Awards
Rapporteur: Teresa lane, VSAA
First Place: Teresa Lane, VSAA
Second Place: James Bryant, SHS
Third Place: Sierra Gernhart, SHS
Honorable Mention: Willie Goforth, VSAA
Rapporteur: Colleen Kimsey, VSAA, The Singing Rapporteur
First Place: Zach Byrd, SHS
Second Place: Colleen Kimsey, VSAA
Third Place: Amanda Beggs, VSAA
Honorable Mention: Ben Bolte, VSAA

 SPEAKING
PRESENTATION is...

* audible
* expressive and self-confident
with good posture
* fluent
*appropriate dress

 POLICY
STATEMENTS
give...

*accurate representation of country
*substantiated position


DIPLOMACY

*respectful in diplomatic attitude,
dress and conduct

*active participant
* substantive contributions to
decision-making process

* helps reach consensus

QUESTIONS & ANSWERS

*Asks well constructed, representative questions
and shows
* knowledge of issue and
political savvy, critical thinking
*logical reasoning
and
*knowledge of UN protocol, documents, history,
philosophy and goals

SPEECHES show
understanding of...


*United Nations and involved countries
and
*affirmative or negative argument(s) are substantiated with strong evidence and analysis, and
* information is relevant and fresh
(not the same as previous speaker's)

LOSING POINTS

* lack of diplomatic respect for
MUN process

* out of character for respective
delegate country

Best Delegation selected by Mike Brinker, 2008 Head Judge
Former SHS MUN Delegate for 4 years, Former Clark College Delegate for 2 years, Currently in Air Force and college
Selection based on speaking and position paper criteria.

First Place: India
Elizabeth Kaley and Emma Hallas
Second Place: DRC (Congo)
Julie Baumgardner and Sierra Gernhart
Third Place: Japan
Zach Byrd and Joseph Fleck
Fourth Place: Turkey
James Bryant and Zach Byrd
Honorable Mention: Egypt
Ben Bolte and Andrew Walker