Established in 1976 by
Mrs. Fran Duncan2008 Awards
VANCOUVER SCHOOL DISTRICT MODEL UN
Dr. Beverly Questad, VSD MUN Coordinator
Skyview High School, 1300 NW 139th St., Vancouver, WA 98685
Phone: 360-313-4200 - - Email -Fax: 360-313-4201
Judging Criteria for Position Paper PreparationPOSITION PAPERS
*Strong research indicated
through elaborations and examples*True country position
Complete and with Professional Voice* Grammar: Fluency and Conventions
First Place: Elizabeth Kaley, SHS
Second Place: Emma Hallas, SHS
Third Place: Sierra Gernhart, SHS
Fourth Place: Julie Baumgardner, SHS, and Nick Shaw, VSAA
Honorable Mention: James Bryant, SHS
Committee One: Mr. Jeremiah Thompson, Moderator
Best Speaker Awards Committee Two: Ms. Jessica Ruso, Moderator
Best Speaker Awards Rapporteur: Teresa lane, VSAA
First Place: Teresa Lane, VSAA
Second Place: James Bryant, SHS
Third Place: Sierra Gernhart, SHS
Honorable Mention: Willie Goforth, VSAA Rapporteur: Colleen Kimsey, VSAA, The Singing Rapporteur
First Place: Zach Byrd, SHS
Second Place: Colleen Kimsey, VSAA
Third Place: Amanda Beggs, VSAA
Honorable Mention: Ben Bolte, VSAASPEAKING
PRESENTATION is...* audible
* expressive and self-confident
with good posture
* fluent
*appropriate dress POLICY
STATEMENTS
give...
*accurate representation of country
*substantiated position
DIPLOMACY
*respectful in diplomatic attitude,
dress and conduct
*active participant* substantive contributions to
decision-making process* helps reach consensus
QUESTIONS & ANSWERS
*Asks well constructed, representative questions
and shows
* knowledge of issue and
political savvy, critical thinking
*logical reasoning
and
*knowledge of UN protocol, documents, history,
philosophy and goalsSPEECHES show
understanding of...
*United Nations and involved countries
and
*affirmative or negative argument(s) are substantiated with strong evidence and analysis, and
* information is relevant and fresh
(not the same as previous speaker's)LOSING POINTS
* lack of diplomatic respect for
MUN process* out of character for respective
delegate countryBest Delegation selected by Mike Brinker, 2008 Head Judge
Former SHS MUN Delegate for 4 years, Former Clark College Delegate for 2 years, Currently in Air Force and college
Selection based on speaking and position paper criteria.First Place: India
Elizabeth Kaley and Emma Hallas
Second Place: DRC (Congo)
Julie Baumgardner and Sierra Gernhart
Third Place: Japan
Zach Byrd and Joseph Fleck
Fourth Place: Turkey
James Bryant and Zach Byrd
Honorable Mention: Egypt
Ben Bolte and Andrew Walker